Episode 57: Stuck Isn't Sick, with Colin MacDonald of Not Therapy

Episode 57: Stuck Isn't Sick, with Colin MacDonald of Not Therapy

Summary
In this episode of Nimble Youth, we dive deep into the complexities faced by young adults who find themselves feeling stuck yet not necessarily sick. Host Matthew Butterman speaks with Colin McDonald, co-founder of Not Therapy, about his personal journey and the insights he's gained along the way.

Key Topics

• The concept that being stuck is not necessarily a mental illness

• Colin McDonald's personal story of wilderness therapy and residential treatment

• The limitations of traditional mental health treatment for young adults

• The role of mentorship and lived experience in supporting independence

• Strategies for parents to help their children move forward

• The importance of boundaries, accountability, and small wins

• Distinguishing between normal struggle and genuine mental health issues

• The impact of AI and online communities on young adults' social interactions

Understanding the Concept of Stuck
Colin McDonald introduces the notion that "stuck isn't sick." This phrase encapsulates the experiences of many young adults who may not fit the traditional narratives of mental health crises but still struggle with direction and purpose in their lives.

"Sometimes it's easier to get some diagnosis that might not necessarily be a hundred percent accurate. Maybe you meet seventy-five percent of the markers... but then you're more likely to identify with your diagnosis and almost use it as an excuse of why you can't do certain things."
— Colin McDonald

Colin's Journey
Colin shares his own story of being sent to wilderness therapy and residential treatment as a teenager. He reflects on how his lack of direction and purpose led to significant struggles, including bouts of depression and anger management issues. His experiences reveal the intricate dynamics between parental expectations and a young adult's quest for identity.

The Role of Treatment Programs
Both Colin and Matthew discuss the traditional treatment programs that many young adults encounter and the gaps often left unaddressed during their transitions back into everyday life. Colin notes that while structured environments provide necessary support, they can leave individuals unprepared for the realities of independence once the support systems are removed.

"When the structure goes away, the support goes away... you're kind of left to your own devices and the parents aren't necessarily prepared to create that structure."
— Colin McDonald

Moving Forward
Colin emphasizes the importance of finding new ways to support young adults—ways that go beyond conventional therapy and treatment frameworks. He advocates for lived experience mentorship, a practice that empowers young people by connecting them with peers who understand their struggles from a personal perspective.

"We're not asking teens and young adults in today's day and age enough."
— Colin McDonald

This conversation sheds light on the intricacies of mental health and the pressing need for a shift in how we perceive and support young adults who feel stuck.

As we reflect on these insights, consider what it means to navigate the challenges of growing up. If you or someone you know is feeling stuck, remember that there are alternatives to traditional paths.

For more insights, tune in to the full episode and explore the rich conversation that unfolds between Matthew Butterman and Colin McDonald.

Links
Not Therapy coaching website

© 2025. All rights reserved.